|
The outcome for mothers and babies of health visitor intervention
Introduction
Over the past fifteen years there has been considerable
interest in the subject of postnatal depression from the
perspectives of both research and primary care.
During the 1980’s a number of prospective studies of community
samples were conducted to examine the prevalence, nature
and course of postnatal depression, and the pattern of variables
associated with its occurrence (see Cooper et al., 1991,
for a review). This work showed that about 10 - 15% women
experience an episode of clinical depression in the early
months following delivery. These episodes are indistinguishable
in terms of their presentation from those occurring at other
times in the life cycle. Thus, in addition to pervasive
low mood, symptoms of anxiety, irritability, loss of energy,
guilt and feelings of worthlessness may be present. Most
episodes remit spontaneously within six months of onset,
although a minority follow a chronic course. Factors that
have been consistently identified as being associated with
the disorder include a lack of a close confiding relationship
and social support, financial hardship and housing problems,
and a previous psychiatric history.
More recently, attention has turned to the possible impact
of postnatal depression on the mother-child relationship.
Most studies have focused on mother-infant face-to-face
interactions, and these have shown depressed women to have
difficulties in sensitively attuning their responses to
the infant (Field, 1984; Field et al, 1988; Cohn et al,
1990; Murray et al, 1993). Rather little is known about
the effects of postnatal mood disorder on general aspects
of caretaking,
Further work indicates possible long term effects of postnatal
depression and associated difficulties in the mother-child
relationship on child development. For example, there have
been reports of poorer cognitive outcome, behavioural difficulties
and more insecure attachments in the one and a half to four
year old children of postnatally depressed mothers (Cogill
et al, 1986; Murray, 1992; Sharp et al, 1995). Notably,
such associations with the postnatal mood disorder are found
even when depression occurring beyond the postpartum period
is taken into account.
This body of work clearly raises important questions about
treatment. Previous reports suggest that, in the normal
course of events, in spite of regular contacts between primary
health care workers and postpartum women, postnatal depression
often goes undetected ( Briscoe 1986; Marks et al, 1979).
Furthermore, even when detected, there is no evidence that
routine care, either in the form of health visitor contacts,
or the psychotropic medication usually prescribed by general
practitioners, is effective in alleviating either the depressive
mood or the difficulties depressed mothers experience with
their infants.
One of the most important areas for research in this area
therefore concerns the evaluation of various interventions.
Previous studies have shown that health visitors, given
brief training in the detection and support of women suffering
from depression, can have a significant impact on the course
of the disorder ( Holden et al, 1989; Gerard et al, 1993).
However, to date, there is no evidence of the impact of
such intervention on depressed mothers' relationships with
their infants, or on the adverse outcomes that are otherwise
associated with this postpartum mood disorder.
A series of inter-related studies is presented here that
were conducted to address the following questions:
i) Maternal experience of infant care: whether the
experience of difficulties in the general care of the infant
differs between postnatally depressed and well women
ii) Health visitor awareness of postnatal depression:
whether, in the ordinary course of health visitor practice,
women experiencing postnatal depression are identified as
depressed and offered more help than non-depressed women;
and
iii) Intervention study: whether training health
visitors in the detection and management of postpartum depression
has benefits, not only in terms of maternal mood, but also
the mother’s experience of both caring for, and relating
to, her infant.
|