|
Health Visitor Training
The Cambridge Health Authority approved a training
programme for all health visitors which comprised
six half days over a period of six weeks. All health
visitors in post at the time of the start of the study
attended at least five of the sessions. The course
was run 3 times. The course was led by a British Association
for Counselling-accredited counsellor who was an experienced
trainer, already familiar with working with postnatally
depressed women, together with a health visitor (SS).
Before formal training started all the health visitors
were invited to an introductory meeting at which their
knowledge of, and attitude to, postnatal depression
was explored.
The aims of the training course were :
- to provide education on the nature and prevalence
of postnatal depression;
and:
- to raise awareness of the value to the mother
and infant of providing treatment.
In addition, training was provided in the assessment
of mood to enable detection of postpartum depression,
and in the management of postpartum depression by
use of simple counselling and cognitive behavioural
techniques.
The details of the training course can be obtained
from the first author.
Briefly, training in the detection of depression
involved instruction in the use of the Edinburgh Postnatal
Depression Scale, together with guidelines on specific
areas which need to be addressed in interview with
those identified by the questionnaire as potentially
depressed.
Training in the management of postnatal depression
and associated difficulties with the infant proceeded
on two fronts:
- basic counselling skills were imparted, using
Egan’s (1982) model of ‘active reflective listening’
and:
- basic cognitive behavioural skills were presented
derived from Cognitive Behaviour Therapy for Adult
Psychiatric Disorders (Hawton et al, 1989). The
focus here concerned the mother’s depressive thoughts,
as well as any problems she was experiencing either
in managing her infant and/or difficulties she was
experiencing in her relationship with her infant.
For practical reasons it was not possible to carry
out a controlled clinical trial. Instead, information
was collected in the period before the health visitor
training, when women were receiving routine primary
care (i.e. the control group), and then again after
training (i.e. the health visitor treated group).
For each of these groups assessment of maternal mood
was made using the EPDS, followed by further enquiries
to confirm a diagnosis of depression. These concerned
the extent of the mother’s low mood over the past
two weeks, her interest in activities she previously
enjoyed, and any feelings of worthlessness or guilt.
Where more disturbance was present permission was
sought from the mother for referral, either to the
GP or Community Psychiatric Nurse.
In addition to the assessment of maternal mood, an
evaluation of the mother’s experience of infant care
was made using a self-report questionnaire (the problem
sheet) covering infant behaviour problems (feeding
and sleeping problems, excessive infant crying) and
difficulties in the mother-infant relationship (infant
demands for attention, separation problems, play and
affection).
The level of depressed mood and the rate of infant
behavioural and relationship problems was compared
for these two groups of women at six weeks postpartum
and again eight to ten weeks later. For the group
identified as depressed after the health visitor training,
regular supportive visits were negotiated with the
mother. Usually hour-long, weekly visits were made
by the mother's health visitor at the mother’s home
for up to eight weeks. Depressed women declining supportive
help at this time nevertheless had, at the time when
the EPDS was administered, the opportunity to express
their feelings and have them acknowledged (as did
well women). Following a two month induction period,
formal evaluation of the treatment programme was conducted
over six months.
During these visits the mother was encouraged to
explore her feelings, often about her changed role
as a mother (whether or not for the first time), while
the health visitor maintained a non-judgmental and
uncritical stance, using the counselling skills of
active reflective listening. Conventional health visitor
advice was withheld during these visits. Where appropriate,
simple cognitive techniques such as problem solving
were introduced, for instance where the mother was
overwhelmed by the practical problems of caring for
the baby.
In the period before health visitor training, 90%
of women delivering at the Cambridge maternity hospital
were screened at six weeks using the EPDS, and where
diagnosed as depressed they also completed the problem
sheet. These two items were also completed at four
months postpartum. Those resident in the city of Cambridge
(n=30) comprise the control group for the present
study.
Following training, 92% mothers were screened postpartum
using the EPDS, of whom 9.3% were found to be suffering
from postpartum depression. All these women were offered
the programme of supportive visits from their health
visitor. During the two month induction period 72%
women accepted the offer of intervention; whereas
in the last month of the study 95% of those offered
help accepted it. Data are presented for the 70 depressed
women who were seen by their health visitors during
the evaluation period.
|